Shchi

What to expect

Taste

Sour first and that is the whole identity of winter shchi. Sauerkraut is lactic-fermented, so its sourness is round and slightly cheesy rather than sharp like vinegar, and it runs through everything. Under it, two hours of beef on the bone gives a deep savoury broth with real body from the gelatine. Cabbage itself is sweet after forty-five minutes of stewing, which is a surprise to anybody who has only had it boiled. Onion and carrot add more sweetness; tomato purée, cooked out for its minute, adds umami and a little acidity of a different kind. Garlic goes in off the heat and stays sharp. Dill is the characteristic Russian herb and is more assertive than parsley — anise-like, grassy, and it defines the smell of the bowl. And then smetana, stirred in at the table, which changes the soup completely: it rounds the acid, adds fat, and turns something sharp into something comforting.

Aroma

Sour cabbage above everything, and it is a strong smell that fills a house — there is a Russian expression about the shchi spirit in a peasant home and it is not a compliment or an insult, simply a fact. Under it, beef broth, and then dill at the end, which is the brightest note. It smells older and more fermented than most soups in this collection.

Texture

Soft throughout, with the kraut retaining a slight fibrous chew that is correct and welcome — it should not be mush. Potatoes are floury and starting to break at the edges. The broth has body from the gelatine and coats the mouth slightly. Smetana adds thickness where it is stirred in.

Sound

Almost nothing for three hours. The only sound worth listening for is at the start: a broth brought up slowly makes very little noise, and if it is boiling audibly the scum is being churned back in rather than rising to be skimmed.

How the flavour moves

Sourness first, immediately. Then the beef broth's savoury depth underneath. Sweet cabbage and carrot through the middle. Garlic and dill at the finish, sharp and green. The aftertaste is long and sour and makes you want bread. Stirring smetana in changes the whole arc — everything softens and the sourness moves from the front to the middle.

Serve it

Hot, and it holds heat well. It is winter food in a country that has real winters, and the twenty minutes of standing at the end is partly to let the flavours settle and partly because it comes off the heat scalding.

Goes with

Dark rye bread, which is not optional in any practical sense. Smetana. Raw garlic rubbed on the bread, which is traditional and excellent. A shot of something cold and strong, in the Russian manner. Where it fails is next to anything else sour, and next to wine, which the fermented acidity destroys.

Cook's notes

Difficulty

Easy and long. There is no technique here, only sequence, and the sequence is unusually consequential.

Cost

Low. A cheap cut of beef on the bone, a jar of sauerkraut, and root vegetables.

Equipment

A large pan for the broth and a wide pan for stewing the kraut. Two pans is the recipe rather than a convenience.

When to make it

Winter, and the day before you want to eat it.

Best season

Genuinely seasonal in origin: the sour version is winter food and the fresh-cabbage version is summer food, and that division is the whole shape of the dish.

You know it is done when

The broth should be clear rather than cloudy, which is what the slow start and the skimming are for. The kraut shreds should be tender and translucent rather than white and squeaky. The finished soup is right when it tastes of cabbage rather than of beef with cabbage in it.

And it feels like

Potato cubes should take a knife tip with no resistance. Kraut should not squeak against the teeth.

Food safety

Nothing unusual. Cool leftovers in a shallow container and refrigerate within two hours, since a large deep pot of hot soup takes a very long time to cool through and spends that time in the range where bacteria multiply.

Where it goes wrong

Tipping raw sauerkraut into the soup pot, which is the fault — it will not soften and you get hot cabbage in liquid. Adding the potatoes after the kraut, after which they never go soft. Boiling the smetana, which splits it into grains in thin liquid. Salting early, when the kraut and its brine are already carrying a great deal. And boiling the broth at the start, which clouds it permanently.

If it does go wrong

Potatoes still chalky: they went in after the acid, and there is no fixing it — the pectin is set. Squeaky cabbage: not stewed long enough, and another twenty minutes in its own pan will help even at this stage. Flat: sharpen with the reserved kraut brine, a spoonful at a time, before reaching for salt. Too sour: more potato, or a little sugar, or serve with more smetana. Cloudy broth: it boiled; next time bring it up slowly and skim.

Making it ahead

Strongly recommended and traditionally expected. Make it the day before. Day-old shchi is a named dish and is better than fresh.

Keeping it

Three days in the fridge, and it is better on the second — see below.

Reheating

To a simmer, and it is the intended use.

Freezing

Three months and it survives well. Freeze without the smetana.

Leftovers

The point. Day-old shchi has its own name in Russian — sutochnye shchi, twenty-four-hour shchi — and is regarded not as leftovers but as the dish properly finished. It is genuinely better.

Scaling it

Doubles easily; it is a soup and the only constraint is pan size.

Substitutions

Pork works in place of beef and gives a sweeter broth. Fresh cabbage instead of sauerkraut makes the summer version, which is a genuinely different soup — sweeter, lighter, and usually finished with a squeeze of something sour to compensate. Soured cream stands in for smetana, which is thicker and higher in fat. There is no substitute for the long broth.

Dietary swaps

Not vegetarian as written. A version on mushroom broth is traditional for Lenten fasting and is very good — dried porcini give the depth the beef otherwise provides. Gluten-free and nut-free. Contains milk, declared, from the smetana, which is added at the table and can simply be left off.

Shopping for it

Beef on the bone, brisket or shin. Sauerkraut from a jar or, better, a proper barrel-fermented one from an eastern European shop, which will be less sharp and more complex. Smetana if you can find it — it is thicker and higher in fat than soured cream and behaves better.

Keeping the cost down

Brisket and shin are among the cheapest cuts and are the right ones here — an expensive cut is wasted in a two-hour broth. Making your own sauerkraut costs almost nothing and takes a fortnight of doing nothing, and there is a recipe for it in this collection.

Sustainability

Good. A cheap cut of beef stretched across six portions, a fermented vegetable that keeps all winter, and root vegetables. It is the shape of eating that most traditional cooking has and most modern cooking does not.

Nutrition

Around 380 calories a serving before smetana. Sauerkraut is a fermented food and, eaten uncooked, carries live cultures — cooked as it is here, those are gone, though the fibre and the vitamin C remain. Cabbage is unusually high in vitamin C for a vegetable that stores all winter, which is part of why it mattered so much historically.

Worth it?

Worth it, and worth making the day before. Three and a half hours sounds like a lot until you notice that under an hour of it is work, and the result is a soup with a thousand years behind it that costs about the same as a sandwich. Stew the kraut separately, get the potatoes soft first, and keep the soured cream off the heat.

Where it comes from

Origin

Russia, and it is about as old as Russian cooking gets.

Also called

Shchi — щи. The winter version is kislye shchi, sour shchi; a summer version made with sorrel is zelenye shchi, green shchi; day-old shchi is sutochnye shchi.

Said out loud

A single sound English does not have, roughly 'shchee' — the shch of 'fresh cheese' run together.

What the name means

The etymology is uncertain and probably very old, which is itself informative about the dish's age.

History

Cabbage reached Rus' around the ninth century and shchi is recorded from soon afterwards, which makes it one of the longest continuously cooked dishes in Europe. Its historical importance is hard to overstate: for most of a thousand years, for most Russian people, this and grain porridge were dinner. Two details are worth knowing. The first is fermentation — sauerkraut existed because it was the only way to eat cabbage through a five-month winter, and the sourness of winter shchi is not a flavour choice but a consequence of preservation. The second is that shchi travelled frozen: in Siberia it was cooked, poured into shallow moulds, frozen solid and carried on journeys as blocks, to be chipped off and reheated. That is documented and it is one of the more remarkable pieces of pre-refrigeration logistics in food history.

Why it matters

It is the Russian national soup and the one every cook is judged on. The day-old version having its own name says something about how seriously the improvement is taken. It is also strongly associated with the Russian stove, the pech, in which a pot could sit at a falling temperature for many hours — which is exactly the cooking method the dish was designed around.

When it is eaten

Every day, and in winter. There is nothing ceremonial about it.

The traditional way

Stewing the sauerkraut separately before it joins the soup, and the very long slow cook. In a traditional Russian stove the whole thing would be left overnight at a declining heat, which is exactly what makes sutochnye shchi better.

How it changed

Potatoes arrived, which is a nineteenth-century change — Russian cooking before the potato used grain or turnip. Tomato purée is more recent still. Neither is traditional in the long view and both are now standard.

Regional variations

The fresh-cabbage summer version, the sorrel version, and a Lenten mushroom-broth version are all standard rather than variations. Some regions add a spoonful of buckwheat or barley. Wealthier versions historically included several meats at once.

How this version differs

It uses potatoes and tomato purée, both modern. Where it is more explicit than most is the ordering — kraut stewed separately, potatoes before the acid, smetana off the heat — and each of those is a correction for a genuinely common mistake.

Sources and credit

None. Traditional and unauthored.

Related recipes

Categories