Crumpets

What to expect

Taste

Yeasty and faintly sour, and that is the point of the long prove — a crumpet made with baking powder alone tastes of nothing much, and the ninety minutes are there for flavour as well as lift. Under it, milk gives a soft sweetness and the salt is more assertive than in most breads. There is a faint mineral, almost soapy edge from the bicarbonate, which is characteristic and correct in small amounts and unpleasant if you overdo it. The crumpet itself is a fairly plain-tasting thing, which is deliberate — it is a delivery system for butter, and anything more assertive would fight it.

Aroma

Strongly yeasty at the end of the prove, which is the cue that it is ready. On the griddle it smells of warm bread and milk. And then the toaster, which is where the real smell happens — toasted crumpet is a specific and instantly recognisable British domestic smell, and it is the Maillard reaction on a surface full of holes, which gives it far more browned area than a slice of bread has.

Texture

Two textures on one object, which is the pleasure of it. Toasted, the holed top face is crisp and slightly chewy, and the interior is soft, spongy and almost damp. Butter melts into the holes and reaches the middle, so a properly buttered crumpet is wet in the centre and crisp on top. Untoasted it is soft, pale and rather uninteresting, which is why it is only half made.

Sound

Very little on the griddle. The most useful sound is the toaster and the crunch afterwards, which should be audible — a crumpet that gives no crunch has not been toasted enough or has no holes.

How the flavour moves

Butter first, because there is a great deal of it and it is sitting in the holes. Then the toasted crisp surface, then the soft yeasty interior. It is a short arc and an entirely satisfying one. Whatever goes on top — honey, jam, Marmite, a poached egg — arrives before the crumpet does and the crumpet is the background.

Serve it

Hot, straight from the toaster, buttered immediately. A crumpet that has cooled for two minutes is a considerably worse object, because the butter stops running and sits on the surface.

Goes with

Butter, and a lot of it. Beyond that: honey, jam, Marmite, cheese melted under a grill, a poached egg. Strong tea. It is a teatime and a breakfast food and it belongs to cold weather, dark afternoons and the specific British institution of eating something buttered at four o'clock.

Cook's notes

Difficulty

Easy in every step and genuinely fiddly to get right first time, because the two variables — batter consistency and griddle heat — both have to be right and neither has a number attached. The recipe gives descriptions instead, which is the honest approach.

Cost

Very low. Flour, milk, yeast.

Equipment

Crumpet rings, or metal cooking rings, or well-cleaned tuna tins with both ends removed, which is the traditional improvisation and works. A heavy flat pan or griddle.

When to make it

Cold afternoons. Make a batch on a Sunday and freeze them.

Best season

None, though they belong to winter.

You know it is done when

Holes opening across the whole surface and staying open — not opening and closing over, which means the batter is too stiff. The shine goes off the top and it becomes matte and dry to a fingertip. That is the moment to turn it.

And it feels like

The top should be dry to touch with no wet batter under the surface. The interior should be soft and slightly spongy rather than doughy.

Food safety

Nothing to manage. Metal rings straight off a griddle are hot and do not look it.

Where it goes wrong

A griddle that is too hot, which is the fault — scorched base, no holes. Batter too stiff, so the bubbles cannot break the surface. Batter too loose, so it runs out under the rings. Not beating the batter hard enough at the start. Browning the second side. And not oiling the rings between batches, after which they stick.

If it does go wrong

No holes: the batter was too thick, or the heat too high, or it was not beaten enough. Add a spoonful of water and turn the heat down. Holes that open and close over: too thick. Batter escaping under the rings: too loose — a spoonful of flour. Stuck in the rings: run a knife round and oil more next time. Soapy taste: too much bicarbonate. Doughy middle: the heat was too high and the outside set first.

Making it ahead

Cook them all and freeze them. That is the intended use — a homemade crumpet is not meant to be eaten within the hour, it is meant to go in a bag.

Keeping it

Three days in a bag at room temperature. They are made to be kept and toasted, which is unusual.

Reheating

The toaster, which is not reheating — it is the second half of the cooking, and a crumpet has never been finished until it has been in one.

Freezing

They freeze exceptionally well and toast straight from frozen. This is the best use of the recipe: make a batch, freeze them, and have proper crumpets on a Tuesday.

Leftovers

There is no such thing. A crumpet three days old is a crumpet.

Scaling it

Freely. The constraint is how many rings fit in the pan, and cooking ten crumpets four at a time takes half an hour.

Substitutions

Strong bread flour matters — plain flour has less protein and gives weaker bubble walls and fewer holes. Water can replace the milk for a leaner, chewier crumpet, which is closer to some traditional recipes. There is no substitute for the bicarbonate.

Dietary swaps

Vegetarian. Vegan with a plant milk, which works well. Not gluten-free — the gluten is doing structural work that no substitute replicates in a batter this wet. Contains cereals containing gluten and milk, both declared.

Shopping for it

Strong white bread flour. Instant yeast. Crumpet rings, or improvise. Nothing here needs a special trip.

Keeping the cost down

It is already almost free. Tuna tins with both ends removed are the traditional substitute for crumpet rings and work perfectly.

Sustainability

Low impact — flour, milk and yeast, and they freeze, so nothing is wasted.

Nutrition

Around 180 calories each before butter, which is where the real arithmetic happens. They are largely carbohydrate with some protein from the milk and flour, and they are lower in fat than almost any other baked thing here — until buttered.

Worth it?

Worth making once for the understanding, and worth repeating if you like the result — a homemade crumpet is chewier and more yeasty than a commercial one, which some people prefer and some do not. What it definitely gives you is an answer to how the holes get there, which turns out to be one of the more elegant pieces of domestic chemistry in this collection. Keep the griddle low.

Where it comes from

Origin

Britain.

Also called

Crumpet. A pikelet is the same batter cooked without a ring, so it spreads thin and flat — the word is used in the Midlands and the north and in Australia, sometimes for what the south would call a crumpet. An English muffin is a different thing entirely: a dough rather than a batter, kneaded, proved and griddled, and split rather than sliced.

Said out loud

As it looks.

What the name means

Uncertain. A crompid cake is recorded in Middle English and appears to mean a curled or bent cake, which may describe a thin griddle cake curling at the edges. The etymology is not settled.

History

Griddle cooking is older than domestic ovens in Britain, and cakes of wet batter cooked on a bakestone are genuinely ancient. What makes the modern crumpet is the second leavening: bicarbonate of soda became a domestic ingredient in the nineteenth century, and it is what produces the open holes right through the batter. So the crumpet as anybody now recognises it is Victorian, and its ancestors are much older and had no holes. There is a modern footnote worth knowing: British commercial crumpet production has twice been halted by national shortages of carbon dioxide, in 2018 and again in 2021 — the gas is used in the packaging, and the resulting crumpet shortages were treated as genuine news.

Why it matters

It is tied to a specific and slightly dated British ritual — tea, a fire, a cold afternoon — and it has an affection attached to it that is out of proportion to what it is. It is also, as a word, a piece of mid-century British slang for an attractive person, which is why the name occasionally raises a smile.

When it is eaten

Teatime, breakfast, and cold weather. It is a winter object.

The traditional way

Rings on a bakestone or griddle, low heat, one side only. Some traditional recipes use a straight yeast batter with no bicarbonate and rely on a very wet batter and a long prove; those crumpets have fewer and less regular holes, which is why the two-stage method won.

How it changed

Very little, and it has been thoroughly industrialised — the commercial crumpet is genuinely good and is what most people eat, which makes homemade ones a matter of interest rather than necessity.

Regional variations

The crumpet-pikelet-muffin vocabulary is regional and genuinely confusing. Scotland has its own crumpet, which is a thin drop scone and not this at all.

How this version differs

It does not. What it adds is the reasoning behind the two instructions people most often break — beat the batter hard, and keep the griddle low.

Sources and credit

None. Traditional and unauthored.

Related recipes

Categories