Vareniki

What to expect

Taste

Onion, and it is what makes the difference between vareniki and a bag of boiled potato. Onions fried properly in butter until brown are sweet and deep, and there are two onions in a filling for four. Potato is bland and starchy by design — it is a carrier. The dough is plain, faintly salty and eggy. Butter is the third flavour and is generous. And then smetana, which is the acid: soured cream against butter, potato and onion is the whole balance of the dish, and vareniki eaten without it are heavy going. Dill is the finish. Nothing here is complicated and the pleasure is in the combination rather than in any component.

Aroma

Frying onions in butter for the length of time this takes, which is one of the best domestic smells there is. Then boiling dough, which smells of very little. Dill at the end.

Texture

Soft against soft, which is the honest description — tender dough around smooth mashed potato, with the fried onions supplying the only textural contrast. That is why the onions go both inside and on top, and it is why frying leftovers is such an improvement: a crisp face changes the dish completely. The sealed edge is the thickest part and should be tender rather than chewy.

Sound

Almost nothing. The onions frying is the only sustained sound, and the dumplings going into water make a brief clatter. Boiling vareniki are silent, and their rising to the surface is a visual cue rather than an audible one.

How the flavour moves

Butter first. Then the dough, plain and soft. Then the filling arriving sweet with onion. Smetana cuts across all of it. The finish is buttery and mild and quite long, which is why the soured cream and the dill are not garnishes.

Serve it

Hot, and served immediately in butter — they stick together as they cool and go doughy.

Goes with

Smetana, which is effectively part of the dish. Fried onions. Dill. A green salad with a sharp dressing afterwards. Cold vodka. A bowl of borsch beforehand, which is the traditional Ukrainian order of things. Where they fail is next to anything else soft and starchy.

Cook's notes

Difficulty

Easy in every component and long in the doing. Making forty dumplings by hand is an hour of repetitive work, and it is traditionally done by more than one person for exactly that reason.

Cost

Very low. Flour, potatoes, onions and butter.

Equipment

A rolling pin, a round cutter or a glass, and a wide pan. Nothing else.

When to make it

Winter, weekends, and Christmas Eve.

Best season

None, except that the sour cherry version is genuinely a summer dish.

You know it is done when

They rise to the surface and then swell slightly and go slightly translucent. The seal should still be intact, which is the real test.

And it feels like

The dough should be tender all the way through with no chalky raw patch at the folded edge, which is where a doubled thickness of dough sits and where under-cooking shows.

Food safety

Nothing unusual. Everything is cooked.

Where it goes wrong

A warm filling, which is the fault — it steams inside the dough, softens the seal from within, and the dumplings burst. A badly sealed edge, for the same result. Rolling the dough too thick, which gives a doughy dumpling with a chalky seam. Boiling too violently, which knocks them apart. Taking them out the moment they float, before the thick sealed edge has cooked. And not dressing them in butter immediately, after which they stick into a single mass.

If it does go wrong

Burst in the water: warm filling, or a poor seal, or too vigorous a boil. Doughy: rolled too thick. Chalky at the edge: taken out too early — give them another two minutes after they float. Stuck together: they were not buttered immediately. Bland: the onions were not browned enough, and salt.

Making it ahead

Freeze them raw, which is the correct way to use this recipe. A tray in the freezer and then a bag, boiled from frozen with two extra minutes. Two hours of work becomes six dinners.

Keeping it

Cooked, two days in the fridge. Uncooked, see freezing.

Reheating

Fried in butter until crisp on both faces, which is a better dish than the boiled one and is what leftovers are for.

Freezing

This is the point of making forty. Freeze them raw in a single layer on a tray, then bag them, and boil from frozen with a couple of extra minutes. They keep three months and turn two hours of work into a twenty-minute dinner half a dozen times over.

Leftovers

Fried in butter, as above. Genuinely better.

Scaling it

Doubles well and the labour is the same per dumpling, which is why they are traditionally made in enormous batches.

Substitutions

The filling is where the variation lives. Sweetened tvorog is the other classic, and it turns them into a dessert. Sauerkraut and mushroom, braised cabbage, or — in summer — sour cherries, which are a genuine Ukrainian tradition and are eaten with soured cream and sugar. The dough is the same in every case.

Dietary swaps

Vegetarian as written. Vegan without the egg in the dough — a water-and-oil dough works and is slightly less tender — and with oil for butter and a plant soured cream. Not gluten-free. Contains cereals containing gluten, eggs and milk.

Shopping for it

Plain flour, floury potatoes, and smetana if you can find it. Nothing needs a special trip.

Keeping the cost down

It is already among the cheapest meals here. Making a double batch and freezing costs nothing extra in time per dumpling and is the real economy.

Sustainability

Low impact — flour, potato, onion and dairy, no meat, and they freeze so nothing is wasted.

Nutrition

Around 610 calories a serving with butter and smetana. It is dough, potato and dairy fat — filling, cheap and not light. The vegetarian filling means it is lower in saturated fat than the meat dumplings it is related to.

Worth it?

Worth it if you make enough to freeze, and a poor use of an afternoon if you do not — the labour per dumpling is the same whether you make twenty or eighty. Get somebody to help, make a large batch, and put most of them in the freezer. Cold filling, sealed edges, and butter the moment they come out.

Where it comes from

Origin

Ukraine, and eaten across the surrounding region.

Also called

Varenyky in Ukrainian, vareniki in Russian.

Said out loud

va-REH-ni-kee.

What the name means

From the verb to boil — varyty in Ukrainian. They are, straightforwardly, the boiled things.

History

Filled dumplings appear across Eurasia and the relationships between them are real but hard to trace: Chinese jiaozi, Central Asian manti, Russian pelmeni, Polish pierogi, Italian ravioli and Ukrainian varenyky are all versions of an obvious idea that spread and mutated. What distinguishes varenyky within that family is size and filling: they are larger and softer than pelmeni, and where pelmeni are almost always meat, varenyky are usually not. That reflects a specific tradition — varenyky are strongly associated with Ukrainian Christmas Eve, Sviata Vecheria, which is a meatless meal of twelve dishes, and with fasting periods generally. The sweet cherry version is a summer dish and one of the genuinely distinctive things in Ukrainian cooking.

Why it matters

They are a national dish and a communal one — making forty by hand is a job for several pairs of hands round a table, and that is how they have always been made. Their association with Christmas Eve and with home is very strong.

When it is eaten

Christmas Eve, fasting periods, Sundays, and any time somebody is prepared to spend an hour shaping them.

The traditional way

Rolling, cutting, filling and sealing by hand. A pleated edge is traditional in some regions and functional in all of them — a wider seal is a stronger one.

How it changed

Freezing changed how they are used more than how they are made. A tray of raw varenyky in a freezer is now normal and it is genuinely transformative for a dish that takes two hours.

Regional variations

The filling is the variation and there are dozens: potato and onion, potato and curd, curd alone, sauerkraut, mushroom, braised cabbage, liver, and in summer sour cherries, blueberries or plums. Polish pierogi are the same construction under a different name. Russian pelmeni are smaller, meat-filled and traditionally frozen outdoors in Siberia.

How this version differs

It is the standard potato and onion filling, with half the onions reserved for the top. That reservation is common and is worth doing because it gives the only crisp element in the bowl.

Sources and credit

None. Traditional and unauthored.

Related recipes

Categories