Fabada Asturiana

What to expect

Taste

Pork fat and paprika, and it is unashamedly both. The chorizo is the loudest thing: Spanish cooking chorizo is heavily paprika'd and its fat renders into the broth, carrying colour and smoke with it. Morcilla brings an entirely different register — dark, mineral, faintly sweet, with onion and often a little clove or cinnamon depending on the maker. The smoked belly adds salt and smoke. Against all that, the beans themselves are mild, buttery and slightly sweet, and they are the reason the dish is not overwhelming: 500g of them absorb and dilute everything. Saffron is a floral, honeyed, faintly bitter note that sits above the smoke and is easy to miss until it is absent. Salt goes in at the end and needs to be judged carefully, because three cured meats have been leaching into the pot for three hours.

Aroma

Smoked paprika above everything, from the moment the chorizo starts giving up its fat. Under it, pork, bay, and a sweet vegetal note from the onion. Saffron shows up in the last hour and is the most distinctive smell in the pot. It is a heavy, warm, unmistakably Spanish smell and it takes over a house for an afternoon.

Texture

Creamy beans that hold their shape until they are in your mouth, in a broth that is thick without being thickened — the body comes from starch leached out of the beans over three hours, not from flour or purée. Against that, the meats are firm and chewy and the morcilla is soft and slightly crumbly. There should be no grittiness and no skins floating loose.

Sound

Almost silent for three hours, which is correct — an audible bubble means it is too hot. The only sound in the method is the pot being shaken by its handles, and that quiet slosh every half hour is the rhythm of cooking it.

How the flavour moves

Smoked paprika and fat first, immediately. Then the beans' mildness across the middle, which is the relief. Morcilla shows up late and darkly. The finish is long, smoky and quite fatty, and it is why the traditional accompaniment is cider — Asturian cider is sharp, still and slightly funky, and it cuts through this dish in a way wine does not. Across a bowl it becomes progressively richer, which is why the portions are one course rather than a starter.

Serve it

Hot, and it holds heat extraordinarily well because of its density and its fat. A bowl stays hot for a long time, which matters in a dish from a cold wet region.

Goes with

Asturian sidra, poured from a height to aerate it, which is a genuine local ritual and a genuinely good match — the acidity is the only thing that stands up to the fat. Failing that, a sharp dry cider or a rustic red. Crusty bread. Nothing before it and, traditionally, only something very light after. Where it fails is next to anything else rich, and next to delicate wine, which it flattens completely.

Cook's notes

Difficulty

Easy and slow, with one thing that genuinely requires discipline: not stirring. The temptation is constant and the whole texture of the dish depends on resisting it.

Cost

Moderate. The beans and the Spanish sausages are both specialist purchases and neither is expensive; it feeds six substantially.

Equipment

A wide, heavy pot — wide matters, because the beans should sit in a shallow layer rather than a deep one, and depth is what makes them break. Nothing else.

When to make it

Winter, and the day before you want to eat it.

Best season

None in the ingredients; entirely a winter dish by temperament.

You know it is done when

The broth thickens from watery to glossy and turns deep orange as the paprika-stained fat from the chorizo emulsifies into it. The beans should be whole and intact, not split, with their skins on. If the pot is cloudy with fragments of skin, it was stirred or boiled.

And it feels like

A bean should be completely creamy inside with no chalky centre, and should still hold its shape between your fingers before collapsing. That combination — intact and creamy — is what the whole method is for.

Food safety

Nothing unusual. Red kidney beans require a hard boil to destroy a toxin; white beans of this kind do not, and the slow simmer here is safe. Cool it quickly if you are resting it overnight, and refrigerate rather than leaving a large pot on the stove.

Where it goes wrong

Stirring, which is the fault and is almost irresistible. Boiling rather than trembling, which does the same damage faster. A deep narrow pot, where the weight of beans above crushes those below. Salting at the start — see the honest note above about whether this actually matters, and do it at the end anyway. Old beans, which may never soften. And skipping the overnight rest, which costs you most of the improvement.

If it does go wrong

Beans still hard after three hours: they were old, or the water is very hard, or something acidic got in. Keep going, add hot water, and accept that some batches never get there. Cloudy and mealy: it was stirred or boiled. Too salty: there is no fix except more water and more beans, so taste before salting. Thin: cook uncovered for longer, or crush a ladleful of beans and stir — carefully — back in. Greasy rather than glossy: chill it and lift the set fat off, which is the standard remedy.

Making it ahead

Essential rather than optional. Cook it the day before, cool it, refrigerate it, and reheat gently. The broth thickens and the flavour settles, and the difference is large.

Keeping it

Four days in the fridge and it is better on day two. It thickens considerably as it cools.

Reheating

Very gently, with hot water stirred — carefully — to loosen. This is a dish designed around being reheated.

Freezing

Three months and it survives well. Freeze it before it has been reduced to its final thickness, since it will thicken further.

Leftovers

Excellent, and traditionally what the dish is for. Thinned with stock it becomes a soup; the beans alone are good with a fried egg.

Scaling it

Doubles, provided the pot is wide rather than deep. Depth is the enemy here.

Substitutions

The beans are the one thing with no good substitute. Fabes are unusually large, flat and thin-skinned and they cook to a creamy, intact texture that a haricot or a cannellini does not reach — a butter bean is the closest common alternative. Spanish cooking chorizo is not the cured slicing kind and the difference matters: cooking chorizo is soft, raw and releases its paprika-stained fat into the broth, which is where the orange colour comes from. Morcilla is a smoked Spanish blood sausage and black pudding is a reasonable stand-in.

Dietary swaps

Not adaptable — it is a pork dish and the meats make the broth. Naturally gluten-free if the sausages are, which most Spanish ones are but not all. Dairy-free and nut-free.

Shopping for it

Fabes de la Granja if you can find them, and buy them from somewhere with turnover — dried beans that have sat for years may never cook properly. Spanish cooking chorizo, not the cured slicing kind. Morcilla de Asturias, which is smoked and firmer than most black puddings. Real saffron threads.

Keeping the cost down

Buy the beans and the compango from a Spanish grocer rather than a supermarket, where the markup is large. Fabes are expensive per kilo and 500g feeds six, so the cost per bowl is modest. Butter beans are a cheaper and acceptable substitute if fabes are out of reach, and the dish will be good rather than authentic.

Sustainability

Mixed and worth stating plainly. Beans are among the most efficient protein crops there are and make up the bulk of this dish; the three pork products are the opposite. As a way of feeding six people on 550g of meat it is a reasonable trade.

Nutrition

Around 720 calories a serving, and it is a heavy dish — three cured pork products in one pot. Against that, 500g of beans between six people is a great deal of fibre and plant protein, and chilling overnight lets you remove a substantial amount of the set fat if you want to. It is a genuine winter meal and not an everyday one.

Worth it?

Worth it if you can get the beans, and genuinely diminished if you cannot. This is a dish about a specific ingredient and a specific texture, and the whole elaborate method — cold start, scaring, shaking rather than stirring — exists to protect a thin-skinned bean. Cook it the day before, do not stir it, and drink cider with it.

Where it comes from

Origin

Asturias, on Spain's northern Atlantic coast.

Also called

Fabada asturiana. The beans are fabes de la Granja and the meats together are the compango.

Said out loud

fa-BAH-da as-too-ree-AH-na.

What the name means

From faba, the bean — the same Latin root as the English fava. The dish is named after its bean rather than its meat, which is the correct emphasis.

History

Asturias is green, wet and mountainous, with an Atlantic climate closer to Ireland's than to Andalusia's, and its cooking reflects that: dairy, cider, pork and beans rather than olive oil and tomatoes. The faba de la Granja is a large flat white bean grown there and now protected by a European geographical indication, and the dish is built entirely around its particular property — a very thin skin and a creamy interior that will not survive rough handling. The dish is usually dated to the nineteenth century, and it became a national emblem in the twentieth, when tinned versions carried it across Spain. It is one of a small number of Spanish dishes better known outside its region than most regional food ever gets.

Why it matters

It is Asturias in a bowl and is treated as such, with restaurants and festivals built around it. It is also winter food in a region that genuinely has winters, which most of Spain does not, and eating it in August is regarded locally as slightly eccentric.

When it is eaten

Winter, Sundays, and family meals. It is a single-course dish and is served as one.

The traditional way

Three things, all named. The cold start and skim, which produces a clear broth. Asustar las fabes — scaring the beans, adding a splash of cold water to interrupt the boil, which is done to stop the skins bursting. And never stirring, only shaking the pot by the handles.

How it changed

Tinned fabada is a real and widely eaten product in Spain and is not held in contempt the way tinned versions of most dishes are. Otherwise the method has stayed remarkably fixed.

Regional variations

Within Asturias the compango varies by butcher and by household. Elsewhere in northern Spain there are close relatives — the alubiada, the pote asturiano with cabbage and potato, and Galicia's caldo gallego, which is leaner and includes greens.

How this version differs

It does not. This is the traditional method written out with its reasons attached.

Sources and credit

None. Traditional, with the bean's protected status a matter of record.

Related recipes

Categories